The Urban Developer
AdvertiseEventsWebinarsUrbanity
Industry Excellence
Urban Leader
Sign In
Membership
Latest
Menu
Location
Sector
Category
Content
Type
Newsletters
Urban Leader Awards Logos RGB White
NOMINATIONS CLOSE SEPTEMBER 12 RECOGNISING THE INDIVIDUALS BEHIND THE PROJECTS
NOMINATIONS CLOSING SEPTEMBER 12 URBAN LEADER AWARDS
LEARN MOREDETAILS
TheUrbanDeveloper
Follow
About
About Us
Membership
Awards
Events
Webinars
Listings
Resources
Terms & Conditions
Commenting Policy
Privacy Policy
Republishing Guidelines
Editorial Charter
Complaints Handling Policy
Contact
General Enquiries
Advertise
Contribution Enquiry
Project Submission
Membership Enquiry
Newsletter
Stay up to date and with the latest news, projects, deals and features.
Subscribe
ADVERTISEMENT
SHARE
print
Print
ResidentialRalph NicholsonThu 11 Jan 24

Bushfire Risks End Seniors Village Plans

Lourdes Hero

An independent planning panel has reversed a decision that would have allowed expansion of a retirement village on the edge of Sydney’s Garigal National Park, citing what it termed “unresolved bushfire risks”.

In a unanimous decision, a five-person strategic planning panel voted not to proceed with the proposal, which sought to double the size of the Lourdes Retirement Village, 15km north of Sydney’s centre.

The decision was described as deeply disappointing by the village operator, Levande.

The strategy group—part of the Sydney North Planning Panel—said there were key issues with the planning proposal that had been raised in 59 submissions from the neighbouring community.

“In particular, bushfire risks and density distribution, which remain unresolved, and the panel was not convinced that the solution for fire risk provided by the proponent was appropriate for a Special Fire Protection Facility (SFPF),” the panel wrote in its decision.

The panel will ask the NSW planning minister’s delegate “to determine the matter not proceed”.

Further, an “alteration” will be sent to the Department of Planning and Environment asking that a November, 2018 decision approving Gateway Determination be reversed.

Sydney-based retirement living providers Levande—owner and operator of 58 retirement villages across Australia—had wanted to double the size of the Lourdes Retirement Village, Killara.

An illustration of the Lourdes Retirement Home expansion plans by Plus Architecture.
▲ A render of the Lourdes Retirement Home expansion plans designed by Plus Architecture.

Levande’s plans called for a $100-million upgrade of the 40-year-old facility. A series of buildings—ranging from three to six storeys—would include 141 independent living units, a new aged-care facility with 110 beds, and at least 63 townhouses as part of a purely residential development.

The facility would gain a new road network and about 1400sq m would be given over to internal communal space.

But Ku-ring-gai Council refused a planning proposal for the expansion plans, saying it could not be held responsible for loss of life or property because of bushfires.

Lourdes Retirement Home is largely surrounded by bushland and sits next to the south-western-most corner of the 2202ha Garigal National Park, popular with bushwalkers and mountain bike riders.

In a scathing submission to the Sydney North Planning Panel in July, Ku-ring-gai planning officers said the proposal failed to show how it would protect the increased population in the development—including vulnerable elderly—in “an environment of changing climate patterns and the expected increased incidence and severity of fire-related events”.

“This council does not want to be held in any way responsible in the event of a bushfire-related incident and any resulting coronial inquest on (the) increase of population at 95-97 Stanhope Road, Killara,” Ku-ring-gai then wrote in a further submission to the planning panel a month later.

“Nor for any loss of life or property elsewhere in the LGA that results from the setting of precedent through the approval of this planning proposal.”

The site is identified as “bushfire prone land”.

Another illustration of the village masterplan: The Sydney North Planning Panel had concerns over bushfires and density.
▲ Another illustration of the masterplan: The Sydney North Planning Panel has concerns over bushfires and density.

In last month’s decision the planning panel voiced similar concerns.

“There was uncertainty as to whether the mitigation of bushfire risks is at an acceptable level given the SFPF, the ‘human’ reaction to fire, and the likely age and fragility of residents,” the panel wrote of its decision.

However, the panel has left the door open for further modifications to Levande’s plans.

“The panel noted a consensus among meeting participants that the Lourdes Retirement Village provided a valuable community service but was in need of redevelopment,” it said.

“However, there was no consensus on the scale and form of any redevelopment.”

It suggested changes to the post-exhibition planning proposal, which it said “may significantly improve a planning outcome for the site”.

Those suggestions included the removal of a narrow environmental conservation zone—replacing it with a so-called Asset Protection Zone (APZ), altering the position of townhouses to provide better fire protection, and repositioning the density and height to achieve a better transition to neighbours to the west of the development.

Levande said the decision was “deeply disappointing”.

“We believe the village, which was built in the 1980s, is overdue for renewal,” a spokesperson said.

“Our proposal provided for every current resident to receive, free of charge, a new apartment, purpose-built for the specific needs of today’s retirees.

“We’ll take some time to examine the panel’s determination in detail before commenting further.”

Residentialdo not useAustraliaPlanningPlanningSector
AUTHOR
Ralph Nicholson
More articles by this author
ADVERTISEMENT
TOP STORIES
Stockland bumps up its apartment pipeline in melbourne and sydney
Exclusive

Stockland Re-Enters Density in $5bn Apartment Play

Renee McKeown
4 Min
Woolloongabba Precinct Vulture St
Exclusive

Brisbane Developer in Cross River Rail Compensation Tussle

Clare Burnett
4 Min
The Mondrian Gold Coast hotel's food and beverage is driving profits
Exclusive

Touch, Taste, Theatre: What’s Driving Mondrian’s Success

Renee McKeown
6 Min
Fortis’ display suites are designed as brand environments first, with tactile details and curated design to build buyer confidence before project specifics.
Exclusive

Relevant or Redundant: Will Tech Kill Display Suites?

Vanessa Croll
7 Min
Exclusive

Missing Heart: Why The Gold Coast Needs a CBD

Phil Bartsch
7 Min
View All >
The Adelaide purpose built student accommodation market is about to increase by 1058 beds with the State Commission Assessment Panel supporting two towers in the making.
Student Housing

Highrise Approvals Add 1000-Plus PBSA Beds in Adelaide

Renee McKeown
JQZ Parramatta EDM
Residential

JQZ Plots 10-Storey Addition to Parramatta ‘Auto Alley’ Plans

Clare Burnett
Stockland bumps up its apartment pipeline in melbourne and sydney
Exclusive

Stockland Re-Enters Density in $5bn Apartment Play

Renee McKeown
The property giant’s strategic shift to higher density is in full flight as details of two landmark projects are made pu…
LATEST
The Adelaide purpose built student accommodation market is about to increase by 1058 beds with the State Commission Assessment Panel supporting two towers in the making.
Student Housing

Highrise Approvals Add 1000-Plus PBSA Beds in Adelaide

Renee McKeown
3 Min
JQZ Parramatta EDM
Residential

JQZ Plots 10-Storey Addition to Parramatta ‘Auto Alley’ Plans

Clare Burnett
3 Min
Stockland bumps up its apartment pipeline in melbourne and sydney
Exclusive

Stockland Re-Enters Density in $5bn Apartment Play

Renee McKeown
4 Min
South Melbourne social housing precinct
Affordable & Social Housing

South Melbourne Housing Precinct Revamp Takes Next Step

Leon Della Bosca
2 Min
View All >
ADVERTISEMENT
Article originally posted at: https://www.theurbandeveloper.com/articles/lourdes-retirement-village-killara-nsw-bushfire